Skip to content

Kids talking to kids – My History Network

I was told once that in the typical social studies classroom, 85% of the conversation is teacher to student, 10% student to teacher and 5% student to student. (And . . . no, I can’t remember the source so I suppose you can adjust the numbers as you see fit.)

But even if the numbers aren’t exactly correct, the point remains.

We talk too much. The kids don’t talk enough. And we certainly don’t let the kids talk enough with other kids.

When the brain spends time reviewing, repeating, experimenting and talking with other brains, good things happen. We need to let the brains of our students spend more time with other brains.

The problem, of course, is to find ways to help kids structure their conversation around the history topics that you are attempting to teach.

So I like what I see over at MyHistoryNetwork. The site is designed to give social studies students the opportunity to talk with one another.

Where high school history students from around the world come together and share, co-operate, challenge, assist and inspire each other.

The site is new and so David Hilton, the site’s creator, is working to generate a group of students and teachers large enough for quality conversations. But I like what I see. Moderated forums for kids, ability to upload content, personalized pages, place just for teachers and specific groups.

It really looks like a useful place to encourage high-levels of conversation to take place about specific content. You could assign your students to talk with others as part of a larger project or simply encourage the conversations by awarding extra credit. The possibilities seem pretty endless.

One of the biggest problems the site will probably experience is that it is hosted at the Ning network. And because many school filtering systems view Ning as a social networking site, it may be blocked at your school.

Of course, that’s the whole point . . . having kids talk with other kids in a structured, content-based way. I could argue that blocking MyHistoryNetwork because it’s a social network is just another way of saying that we don’t want kids to learn in effective ways.

That would seem petty and inappropriate. So I won’t.

(But I’m still thinking it.)

2 Comments Post a comment
  1. Jay #

    You are so right. Teachers talk too much, and what a great concept to create a forum.

    This sounds similar to a blog? I like how students can pose academic questions to other students across the world. This would be a great peer teaching tool. I wold be interested in introducing this into my 8th grade civics class. Do you know if the forum will open up to government topics?

    I plan to ask our TRT about Ning. I never heard of it. I did briefly check out the network and it looks like a tool that can benefit and get students engaged into academics. I will be looking into this more tomorrow. Thanks for sharing.

    November 4, 2009
    • glennw #


      I agree completely! Think of the Ning Network as a poor man’s Facebook. It’s a tool that you can use in a wide variety of ways, with the users of the network able to configure the site anyway they want. So . . . if you or your students want to start a government topics forum / conversation, you just do it!

      The site is moderated and so provides a great tool for encouraging a wide range of ideas among students and teachers.

      The issue for computer system admin folks is that the Ning Network allows the creation of all sorts of sites, not necessarily educational. And it’s easier to just block ALL sites associated with the Ning Network rather than allowing just a select few to get through your internet filter. If they balk, stand your ground and explain the educational benefits of the History Network! (Remember, they work for you, not the other way around!)

      Have fun!


      November 5, 2009

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: