Holiday Goodie Rerun VI: Using evidence and primary analysis worksheets
I’m sure most of you are doing the same thing I’m doing right now. Spending time with family and friends, watching football, catching up on that book you’ve been dying to read, eating too much, and enjoying the occasional nap.
Between now and the first week in January, you’ll get a chance to re-read some of the top posts of 2014. I may decide to jump in with something current but if I don’t, enjoy this Holiday Goodie rerun.
There’s a cool buzz running through the history education world.
Primary sources. Documents. Using evidence. Solving problems. Historical thinking. And that’s a good thing. But I know that it can be difficult sometimes trying to figure out how to use primary sources.
First piece of advice?
Don’t worry so much about primary vs. secondary sources. Start thinking about evidence, about data, instead of focusing just on one sort of document over another. Because if we’re asking great questions, kids will be using all sorts of documents and sources to solve the problem.
I’ve always tried to preach the idea of having kids answer great questions and using a variety of evidence to help them answer those questions. So it’s not just primary sources. It needs to be all sorts of evidence – so kids might need to be using secondary sources. That might be tertiary sources such as a textbook or Wikipedia.
But kids are still using evidence and data to solve the problem. We need to be training our kids how to use that evidence – evaluating, sourcing, and asking questions about audience and purpose. So it’s not really about training them so that they can read primary sources after they graduate – it’s about the long term . . . training them to make better decisions because they now have the ability to evaluate evidence and ask good questions about all sorts of things.
- Who to vote for?
- What news outlet is telling the truth?
- What program being pushed by state Republicans or Democrats is based on facts?
- What car should I buy?
- What college is best for me?
- Should I take that job?
- Is Putin crazy?
- How is this event (or place or idea or person) the same or different than events (or place or idea or person) from the past and how will that impact me?
Second piece of advice?
Don’t re-invent the wheel. Have kids use the different tools already out there as they work to make sense of documents. As we train our kids to think historically, these sorts of analysis worksheets can be great scaffolding tools, especially with elementary and middle school students.
Some of the best document analysis worksheets are those generated by the National Archives and the Library of Congress. But there are others out there. ( And remember – they all can and should be adapted for use with secondary sources.)
- Written Document (PDF) (HTML version)
- Photograph (PDF) (HTML version)
- Cartoon (PDF) (HTML version)
- Poster (PDF) (HTML version)
- Map (PDF) (HTML version)
- Artifact (PDF) (HTML version)
- Motion Picture (PDF) (HTML version)
- Sound Recording (PDF) (HTML version)
Library of Congress:
Analysis Tool for Students
- Analyzing Primary Sources (PDF, 56 KB)
- Analyzing Books and Other Printed Texts (PDF, 61 KB)
- Analyzing Manuscripts (PDF, 71 KB)
- Analyzing Maps (PDF, 55 KB)
- Analyzing Motion Pictures (PDF, 55 KB)
- Analyzing Oral Histories (PDF, 73 KB)
- Analyzing Photographs and Prints (PDF, 55 KB)
- Analyzing Political Cartoons (PDF, 83 KB)
- Analyzing Sheet Music and Song Sheets (PDF, 55 KB)
- Analyzing Sound Recordings (PDF, 55 KB)
The Wisconsin Historical Society has a few tools:
- Document Analysis Worksheet (PDF, 8KB)
- Image Analysis Worksheet (PDF, 8KB)
- Artifact Analysis Worksheet (PDF, 7KB)
- Map Analysis Worksheet (PDF, 8KB)
- History & Critical Thinking: A Handbook (PDF, 615KB)
A version from the University of California:
And if you’ve got a few hours, head over to History Tech for hundreds of primary source ideas, links, and graphic organizers.