2022 midterms + complicated topics = engaged, active, & knowledgeable citizens
One way or the other, things will probably get a bit more . . . hmm, interactive in your classrooms over the next few weeks. As final results from this fall’s midterm elections trickle in and mail-in ballots are counted, you will most likely have some students with questions, parents who may have concerns, and admins who’ll worry about all of the above. Possibly making class discussions difficult and uncomfortable.
And that sort of learning can be difficult. I get that. Throw the current anti-teacher atmosphere into the mix and I can’t think of a tougher time to be an educator. And you’re not alone in being concerned about taking on controversial topics.
Education Week survey data gathered back in 2017 suggested that many teachers find it difficult to talk about race, politics, and other controversial topics. Almost 30 percent expressly avoid it completely. Part of the problem is that many of us – 44 percent – don’t feel prepared to lead conversations that will probably get emotional.
So should you even try? And if you do decide to take on that challenge, what’s the best way to deal with those conversations?
Answer to the first question?
I think too often we failed to focus on skills that our kids need to support a vibrant, inclusive, open, accessible, and empathetic democracy. Too often we concentrate on producing great test takers but not on creating citizens that can listen to others, evaluate arguments, use evidence to make claims, and respect differing viewpoints. Citizens who see the value of diversity, of openness to others, of being part of something bigger than themselves. Citizens who can exchange honest, well-reasoned views on controversial topics.
Our country (and world) needs as many open-minded people as possible who are able to work with others, able to see divergent and different viewpoints, and who can develop solutions to urgent problems. And what better place for students to learn these skills? Who else is better at teaching them than us?
During an interview titled Politics in the Classroom. How Much is Too Much? on NPR, Paula McAvoy, author of The Political Classroom and director of the Center for Ethics and Education at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, asks:
How political do we want students to be? That’s really a question that a lot of communities struggle with and a lot of teachers struggle with. And the point of the book is to say that, in general, to be able to talk about politics is a skill that people need to learn.
And it would be great if it were learned in school because these are great moments in which you bring a group of young people together who are forming their political views. They can really learn to engage across their differences and to start to see that political conflict is a normal part of democratic life.
In a separate interview, McAvoy says that “we need more school-based political discussions in a time of national divisiveness, not fewer.” She goes on:
the main challenge teachers face is finding resources that are current, present multiple and competing points of view, and are the right reading level.
One thing that came out of our research is that students are fascinated by the fact that their peers have different opinions. It opens them up to the idea that the world is complex, that people don’t all think like me, and I still like these people.
And if you haven’t seen this already in your room, kids want to talk about these issues. Generation Z – your kids – want to solve problems. They want to make the world a better place. They’re just not always sure how to do that.
So the simple answer to the first question – yes. We need to find ways to encourage and support controversial and uncomfortable conversations. Because it makes our kids better prepared for the real world.
If you accept the idea that we should be doing this, it would still be nice to have some support and tools. What does it look like? What are others doing that works? Are there resources I can use?
Start by prepping a bit for the conversation:
- Prepare yourself
Before starting any conversation with students, ensure that you are prepared to show up as a facilitator with integrity and poise. You need to understand your own bias before you begin helping kids see theirs. This helps prevent you from being triggered, allowing you to better guide the learning.
Support student self-care
It’s been a tough year. BLM. Protests. The presidential election. Pandemic. Remote learning. All of this can take a toll. Educate students about importance of self-care practices.
- Create a supportive environment and agree on community norms
With everything going on, all of your students want answers, stability, normality. But realize that your students will respond differently to the election’s outcome. Many BIPOC and undocumented kids will have especially strong feelings and concerns. Ensure a supportive classroom with clear and explicit behavior norms. The Choices Program has some helpful suggestions here and here.
Once you laid some foundation, try any or all three of these strategies for tackling controversial topics:
1. Use the Civil Dialogue strategy by a group called Generation Global. They’ve done a lot of work with the Newseum Education people. Start by downloading the incredibly useful PDF. Then develop a clear goal that you communicate to students to help them stay focused and civil.
Civil Dialogue is:
- an encounter with differences
- process for seeking understanding – the goal is not come to 100% agreement
- promotes a non-binary world view. Not right or wrong, not us and them
- Think critically about issues
- engage confidently and genuine curiosity
- understand ourselves and others as complex individual
The strategy encourages best practices (get the details in the PDF download):
- slow down
- say what you see
- say what you hear
- take a break
- reminders about ground rules
- park it
- deal with infractions
- find a bigger question
2. Another effective tool is something called Structured Academic Controversy. It’s a cooperative learning strategy designed to engage small groups of students in the discussion of controversial issues. Through a series of research steps, students add to their understanding of an issue or question. After students have fully explored and analyzed the pro and con arguments on an issue or question, they work as a group to reach a consensus on the issue.
I really like the SAC idea. I used to plan student debates in class. The great thing about a class debate? There’s always a winner. The really crappy thing? There’s always a loser. Exactly the sort of thing we want to avoid if we’re trying to build consensus and teach civic engagement skills. A well run SAC still allows kids to disagree but trains them to respect diverse opinions while using evidence to support their own.
Get details steps to creating your own SAC here. And don’t forget the already created SAC lessons at the Stanford History Education Group.
3. Grab the book Civil Discourse: Classroom Conversations for Stronger Communities by social studies rock stars Joe Schmidt and Michelle Pinkney. Published just a few months ago, it gives you some amazing resources, practical strategies, and handy checklists for facilitating discussions around complicated topics. Seriously. This book should be in every teacher’s tool belt.
Looking for perhaps a wider range of other resources?
- Civil Discourse in the Classroom: Teaching Controversy from Learning for Justice
- Fostering Civil Discourse: How Do We Talk About Issues That Matter? from Facing History and Ourselves
- Your Roadmap for Teaching Controversial Issues from iCivics
- Teaching Controversial Issues in Times of Polarization from NCSS
- “Can We Do This Every Day?” Engaging Students in Controversial Issues through Role-Play from NCSS
Now more than ever, we need citizens able to passionately debate the issues that impact their communities and country. But to participate in the debate calmly and with the ability to see different perspectives – willing to do what’s best, not just what’s best for themselves.
Using these tools and resources can help train your students to become those sorts of citizens.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Glenn is a curriculum and tech integration specialist, speaker, and blogger with a passion for technology and social studies. He delivers engaging professional learning across the country with a focus on consulting, presentations, and keynotes. Find out more about Glenn and how you might learn together by going to his Speaking and Consulting page.
I am currently in a program to become a teacher and one of my endorsements will be in secondary social studies. I am so glad to have come across this blog post. I have been learning a lot about the ideas of democratic education and the importance of having these kinds of discussions in the classroom. I think it is so important to teach students how to have difficult conversations in a way that does not devolve into us versus them. Thank you for providing this resource – I plan to follow up on the book you recommended and am excited to learn more about Structured Academic Controversy!